S T A T E O F N E W Y O R K
________________________________________________________________________
2996
2009-2010 Regular Sessions
I N A S S E M B L Y
January 22, 2009
___________
Introduced by M. of A. ROBINSON -- Multi-Sponsored by -- M. of A. CHRIS-
TENSEN, GREENE, MAYERSOHN, TOWNS -- read once and referred to the
Committee on Judiciary
AN ACT to amend the real property law, the multiple dwelling law, the
multiple residence law, the real property actions and proceedings law
and the general obligations law, in relation to requiring all residen-
tial leases to disclose tenants' rights
THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK, REPRESENTED IN SENATE AND ASSEM-
BLY, DO ENACT AS FOLLOWS:
Section 1. The real property law is amended by adding a new section
235-g to read as follows:
S 235-G. STANDARD LEASE CLAUSE. 1. EVERY WRITTEN RESIDENTIAL LEASE
SHALL CONTAIN THE FOLLOWING CLAUSES:
A. "WARRANTY OF HABITABILITY". THE LANDLORD PROMISES THAT THE APART-
MENT AND BUILDING ARE FIT TO LIVE IN AND NOT DANGEROUS TO THE LIFE,
HEALTH OR SAFETY OF THE OCCUPANTS. UNLESS THE APARTMENT OR BUILDING
BECOMES UNFIT TO LIVE IN DUE TO THE MISCONDUCT OF THE TENANT OR THE
TENANT'S FAMILY OR GUESTS, THE LANDLORD WILL BE HELD RESPONSIBLE IF THIS
PROMISE IS BROKEN, EVEN IF IT IS NOT HIS FAULT.
CONDITIONS WHICH WOULD VIOLATE THIS PROMISE INCLUDE, BUT ARE NOT
LIMITED TO: INSECT OR RODENT INFESTATION, INSUFFICIENT HEAT AND PLUMBING
FACILITIES, SIGNIFICANTLY DANGEROUS ELECTRICAL OUTLETS OR WIRING, AND
INADEQUATE SANITATION FACILITIES.
IF THE PROMISE IS VIOLATED, THE TENANT MAY WITHHOLD FROM RENT THE LOSS
IN THE VALUE OF THE APARTMENT DUE TO THE VIOLATION.
B. "WILLFUL VIOLATION OF LEASE". IF THE LANDLORD OR HIS EMPLOYEE OR
AGENT INTENTIONALLY VIOLATES A PROVISION OF THIS LEASE OR INTENTIONALLY
INTERFERES WITH THE TENANT'S QUIET ENJOYMENT OF THE APARTMENT, THE LAND-
LORD IS GUILTY OF A CRIMINAL OFFENSE.
C. "TENANT'S ASSOCIATIONS". THE TENANT HAS THE RIGHT TO ORGANIZE AND
PARTICIPATE IN THE ACTIVITIES OF ANY GROUP OR ASSOCIATION OF TENANTS.
EXPLANATION--Matter in ITALICS (underscored) is new; matter in brackets
[ ] is old law to be omitted.
LBD01866-01-9
A. 2996 2
TENANT GROUPS HAVE THE LEGAL RIGHT TO MEET IN COMMON AREAS OF THE BUILD-
ING AT REASONABLE HOURS AS LONG AS THESE MEETINGS DO NOT INTERFERE WITH
THE RIGHT OF OTHERS TO ENTER, LEAVE OR MOVE ABOUT THE BUILDING.
THE LANDLORD WILL NOT PUNISH, HARASS, OR EVICT ANY TENANT FOR EXERCIS-
ING THIS RIGHT.
D. "NO EVICTION FOR GOOD FAITH COMPLAINT". THE LANDLORD MAY NOT EVICT
A TENANT OR REFUSE TO RENEW THE LEASE FOR ONE YEAR IN RETALIATION FOR
THE TENANT BRINGING A GOOD FAITH COMPLAINT TO A GOVERNMENTAL AUTHORITY
FOR AN ALLEGED VIOLATION OF THIS LEASE OR ANY LAW OR REGULATION GOVERN-
ING THE APARTMENT.
E. "TRIAL BY JURY". THE LANDLORD AND TENANT HAVE THE RIGHT TO TRIAL BY
JURY IN ANY ACTION FOR PERSONAL INJURY OR PROPERTY DAMAGE.
F. "UTILITY PAYMENT OFFSET". IF THE LANDLORD IS RESPONSIBLE FOR
PAYMENT TO A UTILITY COMPANY, AND IN ORDER TO AVOID A SHUT-OFF OR TO
RESTORE SERVICE THE TENANT PAYS A PORTION OF THE UTILITY BILL DIRECTLY
TO THE UTILITY, THE AMOUNT PAID MAY BE DEDUCTED FROM THE RENT.
2. EVERY WRITTEN RESIDENTIAL LEASE FOR A RESIDENCE IN A DWELLING
HAVING FOUR OR MORE RESIDENTIAL UNITS SHALL CONTAIN THE FOLLOWING
CLAUSE:
"SUBLET". THE TENANT HAS THE RIGHT TO TURN OVER THE APARTMENT TO
ANOTHER QUALIFIED PERSON FOR THE TIME REMAINING UNDER THIS LEASE. BUT
THE TENANT WILL STILL BE RESPONSIBLE TO THE LANDLORD IF THE OTHER PERSON
DOES NOT PAY THE RENT OR VIOLATES THE LEASE IN ANY OTHER WAY.
THE FOLLOWING STEPS MUST BE TAKEN IF THE TENANT WANTS TO TURN OVER THE
APARTMENT TO ANOTHER PERSON:
A. THE TENANT MUST SEND THE LANDLORD A LETTER BY REGISTERED OR CERTI-
FIED MAIL ASKING PERMISSION TO TURN OVER THE APARTMENT. THE LETTER
SHOULD HAVE THE NAME, BUSINESS AND HOME ADDRESSES OF THE PERSON WHO WILL
TAKE THE APARTMENT.
B. WITHIN TEN DAYS AFTER THE REQUEST IS MAILED THE LANDLORD MAY ASK
FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION ABOUT THE PERSON WHO WANTS TO TAKE THE APART-
MENT.
C. THE LANDLORD HAS THIRTY DAYS FROM EITHER THE MAILING OF THE REQUEST
OR THE SENDING OF THE ADDITIONAL INFORMATION, WHICHEVER IS LATER, TO
ANSWER THE TENANT'S REQUEST. IF THE LANDLORD DOES NOT RESPOND WITHIN
THAT TIME, THE TENANT MAY TURN OVER THE APARTMENT.
D. IF THE LANDLORD DENIES PERMISSION WITHOUT GOOD REASON, THE TENANT
HAS THE RIGHT TO CANCEL THE LEASE.
3. IF A RESIDENTIAL LEASE PROVIDES THAT THE LANDLORD MAY RECOVER
ATTORNEYS' FEES OR EXPENSES FROM THE TENANT FOR ANY ACTION OR PROCEEDING
ARISING OUT OF THE LEASE, THE LEASE SHALL CONTAIN THE FOLLOWING CLAUSE:
"IF THE TENANT IS SUCCESSFUL IN THE DEFENSE OR PROSECUTION OF AN
ACTION OR PROCEEDING ARISING OUT OF THIS LEASE, THE TENANT MAY RECOVER
ATTORNEYS' FEES AND EXPENSES FROM THE LANDLORD."
4. A. EVERY MONTHLY TENANT AND TENANT FROM MONTH-TO-MONTH SHALL
RECEIVE FROM THE LANDLORD AT THE START OF THE TENANCY, WRITTEN NOTICE OF
THEIR RIGHTS AS A TENANT. FOR THE PURPOSES OF THIS SECTION, ADEQUATE
NOTICE SHALL BE DEEMED TO HAVE BEEN SATISFIED IF THE WRITING CONSISTS OF
LANGUAGE USED UNDER THE REQUIREMENTS FOR A WRITTEN LEASE PURSUANT TO
THIS SECTION, SECTION 5-907 OF THE GENERAL OBLIGATIONS LAW, SECTION
EIGHTY-FIVE OF THE MULTIPLE DWELLING LAW, SECTION THREE HUNDRED FIVE-B
OF THE MULTIPLE RESIDENCE LAW AND SECTION SEVEN HUNDRED EIGHTY-FOUR OF
THE REAL PROPERTY ACTIONS AND PROCEEDINGS LAW FOR EACH SECTION APPLICA-
BLE TO THE TENANT.
A. 2996 3
B. EVERY LANDLORD SHALL GIVE THE NOTICE REQUIRED UNDER SUBDIVISION ONE
OF THIS SECTION TO EACH OF HIS TENANTS RESIDING AS OF JANUARY FIRST, TWO
THOUSAND TEN.
C. A LANDLORD IS NOT REQUIRED TO GIVE THIS NOTICE TO A TENANT WHOSE
MONTH-TO-MONTH TENANCY IS CREATED BY SECTION TWO HUNDRED THIRTY-TWO-C OF
THIS ARTICLE.
5. A VIOLATION OF ANY PROVISION OF THIS SECTION OR ANY OTHER PROVISION
REQUIRING THAT RESIDENTIAL LEASES CONTAIN SPECIFIC LANGUAGE SHALL BE
PUNISHABLE BY A FINE OF NOT MORE THAN ONE HUNDRED DOLLARS.
S 2. The multiple dwelling law is amended by adding a new section 85
to read as follows:
S 85. STANDARD LEASE CLAUSES. 1. EVERY WRITTEN LEASE FOR AN APARTMENT
FOR WHICH SECTION FIFTY-ONE-C OF THIS ARTICLE APPLIES SHALL CONTAIN THE
FOLLOWING CLAUSE: "THE TENANT HAS THE RIGHT TO INSTALL AN EXTRA LOCK ON
ANY ENTRANCE DOOR TO THE APARTMENT. THE LANDLORD MAY NOT REFUSE THE
TENANT PERMISSION TO INSTALL THE LOCK AND MAY NOT CHARGE A FEE FOR THE
RIGHT TO INSTALL THE LOCK. THE TENANT MUST PROVIDE THE LANDLORD WITH A
DUPLICATE KEY TO ALL EXTRA LOCKS INSTALLED BY THE TENANT UPON REQUEST."
2. EVERY WRITTEN LEASE FOR AN APARTMENT FOR WHICH SECTION
SEVENTY-EIGHT OF THIS TITLE APPLIES SHALL CONTAIN THE FOLLOWING CLAUSE:
"LANDLORD SHALL KEEP EVERY PART OF THE BUILDING IN GOOD REPAIR. HOWEV-
ER, THE TENANT SHALL BE RESPONSIBLE FOR DAMAGE CAUSED BY THE MISCONDUCT
OR NEGLIGENCE OF THE TENANT, TENANT'S FAMILY OR GUESTS."
3. EVERY WRITTEN LEASE FOR AN APARTMENT FOR WHICH SECTION EIGHTY OF
THIS TITLE APPLIES SHALL CONTAIN THE FOLLOWING CLAUSE:
"LANDLORD SHALL KEEP EVERY COMMON AREA IN THE BUILDING, AND THE LOT IN
WHICH IT IS SITUATED, CLEAN AND FREE FROM VERMIN, GARBAGE, DIRT OR OTHER
MATTER DANGEROUS TO LIFE OR HEALTH."
4. EVERY WRITTEN LEASE FOR AN APARTMENT FOR WHICH SECTION SEVENTY-NINE
OF THIS TITLE APPLIES SHALL CONTAIN THE FOLLOWING CLAUSE:
"LANDLORD MUST PROVIDE HEAT SUFFICIENT TO MAINTAIN THE MINIMUM TEMPER-
ATURES OF _____ DEGREES FAHRENHEIT DURING THE HOURS OF _____ TO _____
AND _____ DEGREES FAHRENHEIT DURING THE HOURS OF _____ TO _____ BETWEEN
THE DATES OF _____ TO _____," WITH THE LANDLORD FILLING IN THE LEASE
WITH THE APPROPRIATE TEMPERATURE, HOURS, AND DATES REQUIRED BY LOCAL
LAW, ORDINANCE, RULE, OR REGULATION OR BY THE LOCAL PUBLIC HEALTH OFFI-
CER.
5. EVERY WRITTEN LEASE FOR AN APARTMENT FOR WHICH SECTION THREE
HUNDRED TWO-C OF THIS CHAPTER APPLIES SHALL CONTAIN THE FOLLOWING
CLAUSE:
"IF THE LANDLORD IS RESPONSIBLE FOR PAYING FOR DELIVERY OF HEATING
OIL, AND THERE IS A LACK OF HEAT BECAUSE THE LANDLORD FAILS TO HAVE THE
OIL SUPPLIED, THE TENANT, ALONE OR TOGETHER WITH OTHER TENANTS, MAY PAY
FOR THE OIL DELIVERY AND DEDUCT THE PAYMENT FROM THE RENT. THE FOLLOWING
PROCEDURES MUST BE FOLLOWED:
A. REASONABLE EFFORTS MUST FIRST BE MADE TO INFORM THE OWNER OR HIS
AGENT OF THE LACK OF OIL AND TO HAVE THE NORMAL FUEL SUPPLIER TO THE
APARTMENT DELIVER THE OIL (NOTE: THE TENANT NEED ONLY COMPLY WITH THIS
STEP IF THE LANDLORD HAS CONSPICUOUSLY POSTED A NOTICE WITH AN ADDRESS
AND PHONE NUMBER WHERE HE OR HIS AGENT CAN BE CONTACTED AND WITH THE
NAME, ADDRESS, AND PHONE NUMBER OF THE NORMAL FUEL SUPPLIER).
B. DELIVERY OF FUEL OIL TO THE PREMISES MUST BE SECURED FROM A FUEL
SUPPLIER REGULARLY ENGAGED IN THE BUSINESS AT A PRICE WITHIN THE RANGE
OF PRICES LISTED BY THE DEPARTMENT CHARGED WITH ENFORCING LANDLORD-TEN-
ANT LAWS AND REGULATIONS.
A. 2996 4
C. THE FUEL SUPPLIER FROM WHOM OIL IS SECURED MUST PROVIDE A WRITTEN
STATEMENT CONTAINING THE FOLLOWING:
(1) THE NAME OF THE PERSON OR PERSONS WHO REQUESTED THE DELIVERY; AND
(2) THE DATE, TIME AND PREMISES TO WHICH DELIVERY WAS MADE; AND
(3) THE AMOUNT, GRADE AND PRICE OF THE OIL DELIVERED; AND
(4) A CERTIFICATION THAT THE USABLE FUEL SUPPLY WAS EXHAUSTED BEFORE
THE DELIVERY; AND
(5) THE CHARGE, IF ANY, FOR REFIRING THE BURNER; AND
(6) THE AMOUNTS AND FROM WHOM ANY PAYMENTS WERE RECEIVED."
S 3. The multiple residence law is amended by adding a new section
305-b to read as follows:
S 305-B. STANDARD LEASE CLAUSES. 1. EVERY WRITTEN LEASE FOR AN APART-
MENT FOR WHICH SECTION ONE HUNDRED SEVENTY-THREE OF THIS CHAPTER APPLIES
SHALL CONTAIN THE FOLLOWING CLAUSE:
"LANDLORD MUST PROVIDE HEAT SUFFICIENT TO MAINTAIN THE MINIMUM TEMPER-
ATURES OF _____ DEGREES FAHRENHEIT, FOR THE HOURS OF _____ TO _____ AND
_____ DEGREES FAHRENHEIT DURING THE HOURS OF _____ TO _____ BETWEEN THE
DATE OF _____ TO _____" WITH THE LANDLORD FILLING IN THE LEASE WITH THE
APPROPRIATE TEMPERATURE, HOURS, AND DATES REQUIRED BY LOCAL LAW, ORDI-
NANCE, RULE, OR REGULATION OR BY THE LOCAL PUBLIC HEALTH OFFICER.
2. EVERY WRITTEN LEASE FOR AN APARTMENT FOR WHICH SECTION ONE HUNDRED
SEVENTY-FOUR OF THIS CHAPTER APPLIES SHALL CONTAIN THE FOLLOWING CLAUSE:
"LANDLORD SHALL KEEP EVERY PART OF THE BUILDING AND THE LOT ON WHICH
IT IS SITUATED IN GOOD REPAIR, CLEAN AND FREE FROM VERMIN, RODENTS,
DIRT, FILTH, GARBAGE OR OTHER MATTER DANGEROUS TO LIFE OR HEALTH. HOWEV-
ER, THE TENANT SHALL ALSO BE RESPONSIBLE FOR ANY DAMAGE CAUSED BY THE
MISCONDUCT OR NEGLIGENCE OF THE TENANT, TENANT'S FAMILY OR GUESTS."
3. EVERY WRITTEN LEASE FOR AN APARTMENT FOR WHICH SECTION THREE
HUNDRED FIVE-A OF THIS ARTICLE APPLIES SHALL CONTAIN THE FOLLOWING
CLAUSE:
"A RENT-IMPAIRING VIOLATION IS DEFINED IN NEW YORK CODES, RULES AND
REGULATIONS, TITLE 9, PART 1300. IT INCLUDES, BUT IS NOT LIMITED TO:
(A) FAILURE TO KEEP PREMISES IN GOOD REPAIR, CLEAN AND FREE FROM
VERMIN AND RODENTS, (B) FAILURE TO PROVIDE AN ADEQUATE SUPPLY OF HEAT,
AND (C) LACK OF ARTIFICIAL LIGHTS IN EVERY PUBLIC HALL AND STAIR."
"IF SUCH A VIOLATION EXISTS, THE TENANT SHOULD REPORT IT TO THE DIVI-
SION OF HOUSING AND COMMUNITY RENEWAL. IF WITHIN SIX MONTHS AFTER THE
DIVISION CITES THE BUILDING FOR THE VIOLATION THE LANDLORD DOES NOT
CORRECT THE VIOLATION OR FILE A PLAN TO CORRECT IT, THE LANDLORD MAY NOT
RECOVER RENT FROM ANY TENANT WHOSE APARTMENT CONTAINS THE VIOLATION. IF
THE VIOLATION IS IN AN AREA COMMON TO ALL TENANTS, NO RENT MAY BE
COLLECTED FROM ANY TENANT."
"IF THE LANDLORD SUES TO RECOVER THE RENT WITHHELD OR TO EVICT FOR
NON-PAYMENT OF RENT, THE TENANT MUST DEPOSIT THE RENT SOUGHT WITH THE
CLERK OF THE COURT WHERE THE LANDLORD'S SUIT WAS BROUGHT. AFTER DEPOSIT-
ING THE RENT, THE TENANT MAY NOT BE EVICTED FOR NON-PAYMENT OF RENT."
4. EVERY WRITTEN LEASE FOR AN APARTMENT FOR WHICH SECTION THREE
HUNDRED FIVE-C OF THIS ARTICLE APPLIES SHALL CONTAIN THE FOLLOWING
CLAUSE:
"IF THE LANDLORD IS RESPONSIBLE FOR PAYING FOR DELIVERY OF HEATING
OIL, AND THERE IS A LACK OF HEAT BECAUSE THE LANDLORD FAILS TO HAVE THE
OIL SUPPLIED, THE TENANT, ALONE OR TOGETHER WITH OTHER TENANTS, MAY PAY
FOR THE OIL DELIVERY AND DEDUCT THE PAYMENT FROM THE RENT. THE FOLLOWING
PROCEDURES MUST BE FOLLOWED:
A. REASONABLE EFFORTS MUST FIRST BE MADE TO INFORM THE OWNER OR HIS
AGENT OF THE LACK OF OIL AND TO HAVE THE NORMAL FUEL SUPPLIER TO THE
A. 2996 5
APARTMENT DELIVER THE OIL (NOTE: THE TENANT NEED ONLY COMPLY WITH THIS
STEP IF THE LANDLORD HAS CONSPICUOUSLY POSTED A NOTICE WITH AN ADDRESS
AND PHONE NUMBER WHERE HE OR HIS AGENT CAN BE CONTACTED AND WITH THE
NAME, ADDRESS, AND PHONE NUMBER OF THE NORMAL FUEL SUPPLIER).
B. DELIVERY OF FUEL OIL TO THE PREMISES MUST BE SECURED FROM A FUEL
SUPPLIER REGULARLY ENGAGED IN THE BUSINESS AT A PRICE WITHIN THE RANGE
OF PRICES LISTED BY THE DEPARTMENT CHARGED WITH ENFORCING LANDLORD-TEN-
ANT LAWS AND REGULATIONS.
C. THE FUEL SUPPLIER FROM WHOM OIL IS SECURED MUST PROVIDE A WRITTEN
STATEMENT CONTAINING THE FOLLOWING:
(1) THE NAME OF THE PERSON OR PERSONS WHO REQUESTED THE DELIVERY; AND
(2) THE DATE, TIME AND PREMISES TO WHICH DELIVERY WAS MADE; AND
(3) THE AMOUNT, GRADE AND PRICE OF THE OIL DELIVERED; AND
(4) A CERTIFICATION THAT THE USABLE FUEL SUPPLY WAS EXHAUSTED BEFORE
THE DELIVERY; AND
(5) THE CHARGE, IF ANY, FOR REFIRING THE BURNER; AND
(6) THE AMOUNTS AND FROM WHOM ANY PAYMENTS WERE RECEIVED."
S 4. The real property actions and proceedings law is amended by
adding a new section 784 to read as follows:
S 784. REQUIRED LEASE PROVISIONS. EVERY WRITTEN LEASE FOR AN APARTMENT
FOR WHICH THIS ARTICLE APPLIES SHALL CONTAIN THE FOLLOWING CLAUSE:
"RENT DEPOSITED IN COURT". IF THERE EXISTS IN ANY PART OF THE BUILDING
A LACK OF RUNNING WATER, LIGHT, ELECTRICITY, ADEQUATE SEWAGE DISPOSAL
FACILITIES, OR ANY OTHER CONDITION DANGEROUS TO LIFE, HEALTH OR SAFETY,
WHICH HAS EXISTED FOR FIVE DAYS, OR AN INFESTATION BY RODENTS, ONE-THIRD
OR MORE OF THE TENANTS LIVING IN THE BUILDING MAY BRING A SPECIAL
PROCEEDING IN COURT. THE COURT MAY ORDER THAT THE RENTS DUE AND RENTS
DUE IN THE FUTURE BE DEPOSITED WITH THE COURT TO BE USED EXCLUSIVELY TO
REMEDY ANY OF THESE CONDITIONS.
"NO RENT MAY BE WITHHELD OR DEPOSITED OR DEPOSITED WITH THE COURT,
HOWEVER, IF THE TENANT OR TENANT'S FAMILY OR GUESTS CAUSED THE CONDI-
TION."
S 5. The general obligations law is amended by adding a new section
5-907 to read as follows:
S 5-907. STANDARD LEASE CLAUSES. 1. EVERY WRITTEN RESIDENTIAL LEASE
SHALL CONTAIN THE FOLLOWING CLAUSE:
"LANDLORD'S LIABILITY". THE LANDLORD IS LEGALLY RESPONSIBLE FOR INJU-
RIES TO PEOPLE AND PROPERTY RESULTING FROM HIS NEGLIGENCE OR THE NEGLI-
GENCE OF HIS AGENTS OR EMPLOYEES IN THE OPERATION OR MAINTENANCE OF THE
BUILDING OR THE LOT CONTAINING THE BUILDING.
2. EVERY WRITTEN RESIDENTIAL LEASE FOR AN APARTMENT FOR WHICH SUBDIVI-
SION TWO-A OF SECTION 7-103 OF THIS CHAPTER APPLIES SHALL CONTAIN THE
FOLLOWING CLAUSE:
"SECURITY DEPOSIT". THE LANDLORD MUST PUT THE SECURITY DEPOSIT INTO A
BANK ACCOUNT PAYING THE PREVAILING RATE OF INTEREST. THE LANDLORD MAY
KEEP ONE PERCENT A YEAR FOR ADMINISTRATIVE EXPENSES. THE REST OF THE
INTEREST WILL BE PAID TO THE TENANT EACH YEAR OR TREATED AS AN ADDITION
TO THE TENANT'S SECURITY DEPOSIT.
THE SECURITY DEPOSIT WILL BE LOCATED IN
BANK___________________________
ADDRESS_________________________,
WITH THE LANDLORD FILLING IN HOW THE INTEREST WILL BE DISBURSED AND THE
NAME AND ADDRESS OF THE BANK HOLDING THE SECURITY DEPOSIT.
S 6. This act shall take effect on the first of January next succeed-
ing the date on which it shall have become a law.