NY State Senate Bill 2009-S3142

Senate Bill S3142

2009-2010 Legislative Session

Defines planned retirement community and proscribes rules and regulations for ownership and operation in Suffolk county

download bill text pdf

Archive: Last Bill Status - In Senate Committee Judiciary Committee

Introduced
- In Committee Assembly
- In Committee Senate
- On Floor Calendar Assembly
- On Floor Calendar Senate
- Passed Assembly
- Passed Senate
Delivered to Governor
Signed By Governor

Please enter your contact information

First Name

Last Name

Email Address

A valid email address is required.

Home address is used to determine the senate district in which you reside. Your support or opposition to this bill is then shared immediately with the senator who represents you.

Optional services from the NY State Senate:

Create an account. An account allows you to officially support or oppose key legislation, sign petitions with a single click, and follow issues, committees, and bills that matter to you. When you create an account, you agree to this platform's terms of participation.

Include a custom message for your Senator? (Optional)

Enter a message to your senator. Many New Yorkers use this to share the reasoning behind their support or opposition to the bill. Others might share a personal anecdote about how the bill would affect them or people they care about.

Actions

View Actions

	Assembly Actions - Lowercase Senate Actions - UPPERCASE
Jan 06, 2010	referred to judiciary
Mar 11, 2009	referred to judiciary

2009-S3142 (ACTIVE) - Details

See Assembly Version of this Bill:: A6648
Current Committee:: Senate Judiciary
Law Section:: Real Property Law
Laws Affected:: Add §238-a, RP L
Versions Introduced in Other Legislative Sessions:: 2011-2012: S1941
2013-2014: S3660
2015-2016: S4435
2017-2018: S3818
2019-2020: S4316
2021-2022: S8312

2009-S3142 (ACTIVE) - Summary

Sets up rules and regulations for the operation of planned retirement communities in Suffolk county to provide adequate housing for senior citizens wishing to retire and locate in a planned retirement community; grants owners of homes in planned retirement communities in Suffolk county the right to sell their homes by methods common to sales of residential property; requires that owners of planned retirement communities in Suffolk county offer owners of homes the option to sign a long-term ninety-nine year lease.

2009-S3142 (ACTIVE) - Sponsor Memo

                                 BILL NUMBER:  S3142

 TITLE OF BILL :

An act to amend the real property law, in relation to planned
retirement communities in Suffolk county


 PURPOSE :

This legislation would provide protections to retired persons who
purchase homes on ground 1 eases.  Specifically, the bill would:

1. Call for 99 year leases
2. Require rules and regulations to be given to prospective buyers and
attached to lease
3. A presumption that rules and regulations not uniformly enforced are
arbitrary and capricious
4. Rules and regulations cannot be changed without the consent of the
homeowners and tenants
5. No fees may be added by the retirement community owner in Suffolk
County unless approved by three-fourths of the tenants
6. All rent and utilities must be reasonably related to the value of
the facility or the services rendered.
7. Rent and utility fees must be fully explained when the deposit is
made; failure to do so will result in a failure of the owner to

collect them
8. Any increases in rent or utilities must be in conformance with the
lease
9. The owner shall not:

-require tenants to purchase goods or services from the owner
-require installation and maintenance or repair services to specific
vendors.
-charge a fee to anyone who installs goods
-restrict interior improvements
-interfere wit the sale of a home
-retaliate against tenants for their lawful pursuits
10. Makes it a misdemeanor to deny utilities to tenants
11. Tenants damaged by a violation of these provisions may bring an
action for recovery of damages, plus attorney's fees

 SUMMARY OF PROVISIONS :

Section 1-Legislative Intent
Section 2-Amends the Real Property Law by adding a new section 238-a.
Section 3-Separability
Section 4-Effective Date

 JUSTIFICATION :

This bill would afford to individuals residing in planned retirement
communities the same protections as persons who are mobile home owners
or multiple dwelling tenants.

 LEGISLATIVE HISTORY :

2007-08, S.3815; Similar to A.2528 of 2006

 FISCAL IMPLICATIONS :


 EFFECTIVE DATE :
This act shall take effect October 1 next succeeding the date it shall
have become a law and shall apply to sales, actions, or leases
involving planned retirement community homes occurring or entered on
or after such date.

2009-S3142 (ACTIVE) - Bill Text download pdf

                            
                    S T A T E   O F   N E W   Y O R K
________________________________________________________________________

    S. 3142                                                  A. 6648

                       2009-2010 Regular Sessions

                      S E N A T E - A S S E M B L Y

                             March 11, 2009
                               ___________

IN SENATE -- Introduced by Sen. LAVALLE -- read twice and ordered print-
  ed, and when printed to be committed to the Committee on Judiciary

IN  ASSEMBLY  -- Introduced by M. of A. THIELE -- read once and referred
  to the Committee on Aging

AN ACT to amend the real property law, in relation to planned retirement
  communities in Suffolk county

  THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK, REPRESENTED IN SENATE AND  ASSEM-
BLY, DO ENACT AS FOLLOWS:

  Section 1.  Legislative intent. The legislature hereby finds a need to
provide  adequate  housing for senior citizens in Suffolk county wishing
to retire and locate in a planned retirement community.
  The legislature also finds that  developers  in  Suffolk  county  have
begun selling factory manufactured homes in so-called "retirement commu-
nities"  in which a large parcel of land is subdivided into many smaller
plots.  In these communities, the home purchaser buys and owns only  the
home,  and rents the plot on which the home is installed from the devel-
oper. The developer retains ownership and control of  the  roads,  side-
walks, and common areas in the community.
  This  legislature further finds that the nature of this type of enter-
prise, that is, the purchaser buying only the  home  and  the  developer
retaining ownership of the land on which the home is installed, tends to
lend  itself  to  abuse  and  possibly illegal acts to the prejudice and
detriment of the purchaser.
  This legislature determines that adults of retirement age are a disad-
vantaged group, and as such, require special protection.
  Therefore, the purpose of this act is to extend to the owners or occu-
pants of homes in planned retirement communities at the minimum, (a) the
right to sell their homes including the incidental right to use any  and
all methods common to sales of residential property, and (b) a long term
lease  for no less than ninety-nine years with the sole option to cancel

 EXPLANATION--Matter in ITALICS (underscored) is new; matter in brackets
                      [ ] is old law to be omitted.
                                                           LBD03984-01-9

S. 3142                             2                            A. 6648

said lease on ninety days written notice to the owner  or  operators  of
the planned retirement communities.
  S 2. The real property law is amended by adding a new section 238-a to
read as follows:
  S 238-A. PLANNED RETIREMENT COMMUNITY; SUFFOLK COUNTY. 1. DEFINITIONS.
AS  USED  IN  THIS SECTION:   (A) A "PLANNED RETIREMENT COMMUNITY" SHALL
MEAN A CONTIGUOUS PARCEL OF PRIVATELY OWNED  REAL  PROPERTY  IN  SUFFOLK
COUNTY CONTAINING TWO HUNDRED OR MORE LOTS WHICH ARE LEASED TO OWNERS OF
YEAR-ROUND  HOMES ERECTED THEREON AND AFFIXED THERETO WHEREIN THE PERMA-
NENT OCCUPATION IS RESTRICTED TO TENANTS  FIFTY-FIVE  YEARS  OF  AGE  OR
OLDER.
  A "PLANNED RETIREMENT COMMUNITY" SHALL NOT INCLUDE A MOBILE HOME PARK,
OR  CONDOMINIUM,  AS DEFINED IN THIS CHAPTER OR REAL PROPERTY OWNED BY A
CORPORATION FORMED PURSUANT TO THE COOPERATIVE CORPORATIONS LAW.
  (B) "HOME OWNER" SHALL MEAN ONE WHO HOLDS TITLE TO A HOME.
  (C) "TENANT" SHALL MEAN ONE WHO OCCUPIES A HOME IN A  PLANNED  RETIRE-
MENT COMMUNITY.
  2.  LEASES.  (A) ANY PLANNED RETIREMENT COMMUNITY OWNER OR OPERATOR IN
SUFFOLK COUNTY SHALL OFFER EVERY HOME OWNER OR TENANT THE OPPORTUNITY TO
SIGN A LONG TERM LEASE FOR NINETY-NINE YEARS, WITH THE  SOLE  OPTION  OF
THE  HOME  OWNER  OR  TENANT TO CANCEL SAID LEASE ON NINETY DAYS WRITTEN
NOTICE TO SAID OWNER OR OPERATOR.
  (B) A COPY OF SUCH PLANNED  RETIREMENT  COMMUNITY'S  RULES  AND  REGU-
LATIONS,  IF  ANY,  SHALL  BE ATTACHED TO AND BECOME A PART OF THE LEASE
PROVIDED FOR BY THIS SECTION, AS IF FULLY SET  FORTH  THEREIN  AND  THAT
SAID RULES AND REGULATIONS MAY NOT BE CHANGED, ALTERED, AMENDED OR MODI-
FIED  WITHOUT THE WRITTEN CONSENT OF THREE-FOURTHS OF ALL HOME OWNERS OR
TENANTS THEN IN RESIDENCE.
  (C) NO RULES OR REGULATIONS  SHALL  BE  INCONSISTENT  WITH  THE  LEASE
PROVISIONS IN EFFECT AT THE COMMENCEMENT OF SUCH LEASE.
  (D)  A COPY OF THE LEASE SHALL BE DELIVERED BY SUCH PLANNED RETIREMENT
COMMUNITY OWNER OR OPERATOR IN SUFFOLK COUNTY  TO  ALL  HOME  OWNERS  OR
TENANTS  AT  THE  TIME OF THE FIRST DEPOSIT MADE PAYABLE TO SAID PLANNED
RETIREMENT COMMUNITY OWNER OR OPERATOR.
  3. RULES AND REGULATIONS. (A) THE PLANNED RETIREMENT  COMMUNITY  OWNER
OR  OPERATOR  IN  SUFFOLK  COUNTY  MAY  PROMULGATE  RULES OR REGULATIONS
GOVERNING THE RENT AND USE OR OCCUPATION OF THE HOME LOT, PROVIDED  THAT
SUCH RULES OR REGULATIONS SHALL NOT BE UNREASONABLE, ARBITRARY OR CAPRI-
CIOUS.
  (B)  A  COPY  OF  ALL  RULES AND REGULATIONS SHALL BE DELIVERED BY THE
PLANNED RETIREMENT COMMUNITY OWNER OR OPERATOR IN SUFFOLK COUNTY TO  ALL
HOME  OWNERS OR TENANTS AT THE TIME OF THE FIRST DEPOSIT MADE PAYABLE TO
SAID PLANNED RETIREMENT COMMUNITY OWNER OR OPERATOR.
  (C) A COPY OF ALL RULES AND REGULATIONS SHALL BE POSTED IN A CONSPICU-
OUS PUBLIC LOCATION UPON THE GROUNDS OF THE PLANNED RETIREMENT COMMUNITY
IN SUFFOLK COUNTY.
  (D) IF A RULE OR REGULATION IS  NOT  APPLIED  UNIFORMLY  TO  ALL  HOME
OWNERS  OR  TENANTS,  THERE  SHALL BE A REBUTTABLE PRESUMPTION THAT SUCH
RULE OR REGULATION IS UNREASONABLE, ARBITRARY OR CAPRICIOUS.
  (E) ANY RULE OR REGULATION WHICH DOES NOT CONFORM TO THE  REQUIREMENTS
OF  THIS SECTION OR WHICH HAS NOT BEEN SUPPLIED OR POSTED AS REQUIRED BY
THIS SECTION, SHALL NOT BE ENFORCEABLE.
  (F) NO RULE OR REGULATION MAY BE ADDED, AMENDED, REPEALED  OR  CHANGED
BY  THE PLANNED RETIREMENT COMMUNITY OWNER OR OPERATOR WITHOUT THE WRIT-
TEN CONSENT OF ALL OF THE THEN RESIDING HOME OWNERS OR TENANTS.

S. 3142                             3                            A. 6648

  4. FEES. (A) NO PLANNED RETIREMENT COMMUNITY HOME OWNER OR  TENANT  IN
SUFFOLK COUNTY SHALL BE CHARGED A FEE, CHARGE, OR ASSESSMENT, EXCEPT FOR
RENT  AND UTILITIES UNLESS AGREED TO BY THREE-FOURTHS OF ALL OF THE HOME
OWNERS.
  (B) ALL SUCH CHARGES FOR RENT AND UTILITIES MUST BE REASONABLY RELATED
TO  THE  VALUE  OF  THE  FACILITY  AVAILABLE  OR  THE  SERVICES ACTUALLY
RENDERED.
  (C) A PLANNED RETIREMENT COMMUNITY OWNER OR OPERATOR IN SUFFOLK COUNTY
MUST FULLY DISCLOSE ALL CHARGES FOR  RENT  AND  UTILITIES  TO  ALL  HOME
OWNERS  OR TENANTS AT THE TIME OF THE FIRST DEPOSIT MADE PAYABLE TO SAID
COMMUNITY OWNER OR OPERATOR.
  (D) FAILURE ON THE PART OF THE PLANNED RETIREMENT COMMUNITY  OWNER  OR
OPERATOR  IN  SUFFOLK  COUNTY  TO FULLY DISCLOSE ALL CHARGES FOR RENT OR
UTILITIES SHALL PREVENT  THE  SAID  COMMUNITY  OWNER  OR  OPERATOR  FROM
COLLECTING SUCH CHARGES.
  (E)  NO  CHARGES  FOR RENT OR UTILITIES MAY BE INCREASED EXCEPT AS SET
FORTH IN THE LEASE.
  5. PROHIBITION. NO PLANNED RETIREMENT COMMUNITY OWNER OR  OPERATOR  IN
SUFFOLK COUNTY SHALL:
  (A)  REQUIRE A HOME OWNER OR TENANT TO PURCHASE GOODS OR SERVICES FROM
SAID PLANNED RETIREMENT COMMUNITY OWNER OR OPERATOR, OR FROM ANY  VENDOR
DESIGNATED BY SAID COMMUNITY OWNER OR OPERATOR.
  (B)  RESTRICT  THE INSTALLATION, MAINTENANCE OR REPAIR OF ANY PROPERTY
OF THE HOME OWNER OR TENANT  TO  SPECIFIC  VENDORS  INCLUDING,  BUT  NOT
LIMITED  TO,  EMPLOYEES, AGENTS OR OTHER PERSONS ACTING FOR OR ON BEHALF
OF THE PLANNED RETIREMENT COMMUNITY OWNER OR OPERATOR.
  (C) CHARGE  A FEE OR IMPOSE OTHER CHARGES ON A HOME  OWNER  OR  TENANT
WHO   CHOOSES  TO  INSTALL  ANY  PROPERTY  INCLUDING  APPLIANCES  AND/OR
FIXTURES.
  (D) IMPOSE ANY CHARGE FOR, OR RESTRICT THE INGRESS OR  EGRESS  TO  THE
PLANNED  RETIREMENT  COMMUNITY  OF,  ANY  PERSON  EMPLOYED, RETAINED, OR
INVITED BY THE HOME OWNER OR TENANT, WHETHER TO PROVIDE A  COMMODITY  OR
SERVICE OR OTHERWISE.
  (E)  RESTRICT  THE  PURCHASE  AND/OR  INSTALLATION OF ANY COMMODITIES,
GOODS OR SERVICES BY THE HOME  OWNER  OR  TENANT  TO  SPECIFIC  VENDORS,
INCLUDING  EMPLOYEES, AGENTS OR OTHER PERSONS ACTING FOR OR ON BEHALF OF
THE PLANNED RETIREMENT COMMUNITY OWNER OR OPERATOR.
  (F) RESTRICT THE MAKING OF ANY INTERIOR  INSTALLATION,  FURNISHING  OR
IMPROVEMENT  TO  THE  PLANNED RETIREMENT COMMUNITY HOME, SO LONG AS SUCH
INSTALLATION, FURNISHING OR IMPROVEMENT IS IN COMPLIANCE WITH APPLICABLE
BUILDING CODES AND OTHER PROVISIONS OF LAW.
  6. SALE OF HOMES. (A) THE HOME OWNER HAS  THE  UNRESTRICTED  RIGHT  TO
SELL  HIS  OR  HER  HOME IN SUCH PLANNED RETIREMENT COMMUNITY IN SUFFOLK
COUNTY.
  (B) THE RIGHT TO SELL A PLANNED RETIREMENT COMMUNITY HOME INCLUDES THE
INCIDENTAL RIGHT TO USE ANY AND ALL METHODS COMMON TO SALES OF  RESIDEN-
TIAL PROPERTY.
  (C)  THE  PLANNED RETIREMENT COMMUNITY HOME OWNER'S LEASE AGREEMENT IS
ASSIGNABLE TO A SUBSEQUENT PURCHASER, WITHOUT CONDITIONS OR RESTRICTIONS
BY THE PLANNED RETIREMENT COMMUNITY OWNER OR OPERATOR.
  (D) THE PLANNED RETIREMENT COMMUNITY  OWNER  OR  OPERATOR  IN  SUFFOLK
COUNTY  SHALL  NOT  EXACT  A COMMISSION OR FEE WITH RESPECT TO THE PRICE
REALIZED BY THE SELLER UNLESS THE COMMUNITY OWNER OR OPERATOR HAS  ACTED
AS  AGENT  FOR  THE  SAID  HOME  OWNER IN THE SALE PURSUANT TO A WRITTEN
CONTRACT.

S. 3142                             4                            A. 6648

  7. EMERGENCIES. (A) A PLANNED RETIREMENT COMMUNITY OWNER  OR  OPERATOR
IN  SUFFOLK COUNTY MAY ENTER A PLANNED RETIREMENT COMMUNITY HOME ONLY IN
CASE OF EMERGENCY.
  (B)  A  PLANNED RETIREMENT COMMUNITY OWNER OR OPERATOR SHALL DESIGNATE
AN AGENT ON THE PREMISES WHO CAN BE  CONTACTED  ON  A  TWENTY-FOUR  HOUR
BASIS  TO  INSURE  THE  AVAILABILITY  OF  EMERGENCY  RESPONSE IN MATTERS
AFFECTING THE HEALTH, SAFETY,  WELL-BEING,  AND/OR  GENERAL  WELFARE  OF
PLANNED  RETIREMENT  COMMUNITY  TENANTS.  THE  DESIGNATED  AGENT'S NAME,
ADDRESS AND TELEPHONE NUMBER SHALL BE POSTED  IN  A  CONSPICUOUS  PUBLIC
LOCATION  IN  THE PLANNED RETIREMENT COMMUNITY, GIVEN IN WRITING TO EACH
TENANT, AND REGISTER WITH APPROPRIATE MUNICIPAL LAW ENFORCEMENT,  HEALTH
AND FIRE OFFICIALS.
  8.  RETALIATION.  NO PLANNED RETIREMENT COMMUNITY OWNER OR OPERATOR IN
SUFFOLK COUNTY MAY THREATEN REPRISAL, OVERTLY OR COVERTLY,  AGAINST  ANY
OF  SUCH HOME OWNERS OR TENANTS AS A RESULT OF THEIR LAWFUL PURSUITS AND
ACTIVITIES.
  9. REFUSAL TO FURNISH SERVICE. ANY PLANNED RETIREMENT COMMUNITY  OWNER
OR  OPERATOR  WHO  HAS AGREED TO PROVIDE HOT OR COLD WATER, HEAT, LIGHT,
POWER, OR ANY OTHER SERVICE OR FACILITY TO AN OCCUPANT  OF  THE  PLANNED
RETIREMENT  COMMUNITY,  WHO  WILLFULLY OR INTENTIONALLY FAILS TO FURNISH
SUCH WATER, HEAT, LIGHT, POWER OR OTHER  SERVICE  OR  FACILITY,  OR  WHO
INTERFERES  WITH  THE  QUIET  ENJOYMENT  OF THE LEASED PREMISES SHALL BE
GUILTY OF A MISDEMEANOR PUNISHABLE BY A FINE NOT TO EXCEED FIVE  HUNDRED
DOLLARS AND/OR IMPRISONMENT NOT TO EXCEED SIX MONTHS.
  10.  RECEIPTS.  UPON  RECEIPT  OF RENT, FEES, CHARGES OR OTHER ASSESS-
MENTS, IN THE FORM OF CASH OR ANY INSTRUMENT  OTHER  THAN  THE  PERSONAL
CHECK  OF  THE  TENANT,  IT  SHALL BE THE DUTY OF THE PLANNED RETIREMENT
COMMUNITY OWNER OR OPERATOR IN SUFFOLK COUNTY TO PROVIDE THE PAYOR  WITH
A WRITTEN RECEIPT CONTAINING THE FOLLOWING:
  (A) THE DATE;
  (B) THE AMOUNT;
  (C) THE IDENTITY OF THE PREMISES AND THE PERIOD FOR WHICH PAID;
  (D) THE SIGNATURE AND TITLE OF THE PERSON RECEIVING PAYMENT.
  11.  REMEDIES.  (A)  ANY  PLANNED  RETIREMENT  COMMUNITY HOME OWNER OR
TENANT IN SUFFOLK COUNTY INJURED OR DAMAGED IN WHOLE OR  IN  PART  AS  A
RESULT OF A VIOLATION OF ANY OF THE PROVISIONS OF THIS SECTION MAY BRING
AN ACTION FOR RECOVERY OF DAMAGES IN AN AMOUNT NOT TO EXCEED THREE TIMES
THE  ACTUAL  DAMAGES OR FIVE HUNDRED DOLLARS, WHICHEVER IS GREATER, PLUS
REASONABLE ATTORNEY'S FEES. THE REMEDY SHALL BE IN ADDITION TO AND SHALL
NOT PRECLUDE OR DIMINISH ANY ACTION THAT AN INDIVIDUAL  MAY  HAVE  UNDER
COMMON LAW OR ANY LOCAL, STATE OR FEDERAL LAW OR REGULATION.
  (B)  THE  COUNTY ATTORNEY MAY COMMENCE AN ACTION TO RESTRAIN, PREVENT,
AND/OR ENJOIN A VIOLATION OF THIS  SECTION  OR  A  CONTINUANCE  OF  SUCH
VIOLATION  OF  THIS  SECTION  OR  A  CONTINUANCE  OF SUCH VIOLATION BY A
PLANNED RETIREMENT COMMUNITY OWNER OR OPERATOR.
  S 3. Separability. If any part or provision of this act or the  appli-
cation  thereof  to  a person or circumstance is adjudged invalid by any
court of competent jurisdiction, such judgment shall be confined in  its
operation  to the part or the provision or application directly involved
in the controversy in which such judgment shall have been  rendered  and
shall  not affect or impair the validity of the remainder of this act or
application thereof to other persons or circumstances.
  S 4. This act shall take effect on the first of October next  succeed-
ing  the  date  on  which  it shall have become a law and shall apply to
sales, actions, or leases involving planned retirement  community  homes
occurring or entered into on or after such date.

Comments

Open Legislation is a forum for New York State legislation. All comments are subject to review and community moderation is encouraged.

Comments deemed off-topic, commercial, campaign-related, self-promotional; or that contain profanity, hate or toxic speech; or that link to sites outside of the nysenate.gov domain are not permitted, and will not be published. Attempts to intimidate and silence contributors or deliberately deceive the public, including excessive or extraneous posting/posts, or coordinated activity, are prohibited and may result in the temporary or permanent banning of the user. Comment moderation is generally performed Monday through Friday. By contributing or voting you agree to the Terms of Participation and verify you are over 13.

Create an account. An account allows you to sign petitions with a single click, officially support or oppose key legislation, and follow issues, committees, and bills that matter to you. When you create an account, you agree to this platform's terms of participation.