S T A T E O F N E W Y O R K
________________________________________________________________________
8828
I N A S S E M B L Y
January 18, 2024
___________
Introduced by M. of A. FLOOD -- read once and referred to the Committee
on Education
AN ACT to amend the education law and the public officers law, in
relation to establishing the "public school instructional materials
review and transparency act"
THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK, REPRESENTED IN SENATE AND ASSEM-
BLY, DO ENACT AS FOLLOWS:
Section 1. This act shall be known and may be cited as the "public
school instructional materials review and transparency act".
§ 2. The education law is amended by adding a new article 15-D to read
as follows:
ARTICLE 15-D
PUBLIC SCHOOL INSTRUCTIONAL MATERIALS REVIEW AND TRANSPARENCY ACT
SECTION 731. DEFINITIONS.
732. INFORMAL COMPLAINT.
733. FORMAL COMPLAINT.
734. ACCESSIBLE PUBLIC DATABASE.
§ 731. DEFINITIONS. AS USED IN THIS ARTICLE, THE FOLLOWING TERMS SHALL
HAVE THE FOLLOWING MEANINGS:
1. "INSTRUCTIONAL MATERIAL" MEANS TEXTBOOKS, WORKBOOKS, LIBRARY
VOLUMES, AUDIO-VISUAL RECORDINGS, AND ANY OTHER INSTRUCTIONAL, CURRIC-
ULUM, LITERARY, RESOURCE, OR SUPPORT MATERIAL.
2. "CHALLENGED MATERIAL" MEANS ANY INSTRUCTIONAL MATERIAL FOR WHICH AN
INFORMAL OR FORMAL COMPLAINT BY A PARENT OR GUARDIAN OF A STUDENT WHO
ATTENDS A SCHOOL DISTRICT HAS BEEN MADE.
3. "INFORMAL COMPLAINT" MEANS A PROCESS WHEREBY A PARENT OR GUARDIAN
OF A STUDENT WHO ATTENDS A SCHOOL DISTRICT REQUESTS OF A TEACHER, SCHOOL
PRINCIPAL, OR OTHER SCHOOL OFFICIAL, WHETHER IN WRITING OR VERBALLY,
THAT AN INSTRUCTIONAL MATERIAL IN USE WITHIN THE SCHOOL DISTRICT BE
REVIEWED BY THE TEACHER, SCHOOL PRINCIPAL, OR OTHER SCHOOL OFFICIAL FOR
APPROPRIATENESS IN THE SCHOOL SETTING AND SUBSEQUENTLY BE DISCONTINUED
OR RESTRICTED IN USE BY AGE OR GRADE LEVEL, OR BE MADE SUBJECT TO USE BY
PARENTAL PERMISSION.
EXPLANATION--Matter in ITALICS (underscored) is new; matter in brackets
[ ] is old law to be omitted.
LBD13342-07-3
A. 8828 2
4. "FORMAL COMPLAINT" MEANS A WRITTEN COMPLAINT BY A PARENT OR GUARDI-
AN OF A STUDENT WHO ATTENDS A SCHOOL DISTRICT, TO A SCHOOL SUPERINTEN-
DENT REQUESTING THAT THE SCHOOL DISTRICT REVIEW A CHALLENGED MATERIAL IN
USE WITHIN SUCH SCHOOL DISTRICT FOR APPROPRIATENESS IN THE SCHOOL
SETTING AND SUBSEQUENTLY DISCONTINUED OR RESTRICTED IN USE BY AGE OR
GRADE LEVEL, OR BE MADE SUBJECT TO USE BY PARENTAL PERMISSION.
5. "REVIEW COMMITTEE" MEANS A TEMPORARY OR STANDING REVIEW COMMITTEE
FOR EACH SCHOOL DISTRICT, WHOSE MEMBERS SHALL BE APPOINTED BY THE SUPER-
INTENDENT OR SCHOOL BOARD OF EACH SUCH SCHOOL DISTRICT FOR THE PURPOSE
OF REVIEWING FORMAL COMPLAINTS. MEMBERS OF SUCH COMMITTEE SHALL INCLUDE
BUT NOT BE LIMITED TO STAKEHOLDERS OF SUCH SCHOOL DISTRICT, AS DEEMED
APPROPRIATE BY THE SCHOOL BOARD OR SUPERINTENDENT. A LIST OF SUCH
MEMBERS SHALL BE POSTED ON THE WEBSITE OF SUCH SCHOOL DISTRICT AND BE
MADE AVAILABLE TO THE PUBLIC UPON REQUEST.
§ 732. INFORMAL COMPLAINT. INITIAL COMPLAINTS REGARDING CHALLENGED
MATERIAL MAY BE BROUGHT AS AN INFORMAL COMPLAINT BY PARENTS OR GUARDIANS
OF STUDENTS ATTENDING A SCHOOL DISTRICT TO A TEACHER, DEPARTMENT CHAIR,
PRINCIPAL OF A SCHOOL, ASSISTANT SUPERINTENDENT OF A SCHOOL DISTRICT, OR
OTHER SCHOOL ADMINISTRATIVE PERSONNEL. SUCH INFORMAL COMPLAINT ABOUT A
CHALLENGED MATERIAL MAY BE RESOLVED BY MUTUAL AGREEMENT OF THE COMPLAIN-
ANT AND THE SCHOOL PERSONNEL TO WHOM SUCH COMPLAINANT BROUGHT THE
MATTER. IF SUCH RESOLUTION IS NOT REACHED TO THE COMPLAINANT'S SATISFAC-
TION, THE COMPLAINANT MAY FILE A FORMAL COMPLAINT.
§ 733. FORMAL COMPLAINT. 1. WHEN A PARENT OR GUARDIAN OF A STUDENT
ATTENDING A SCHOOL DISTRICT SUBMITS A FORMAL COMPLAINT TO A SUPERINTEN-
DENT OF SUCH SCHOOL DISTRICT, THE SUPERINTENDENT SHALL REFER SUCH FORMAL
COMPLAINT TO A REVIEW COMMITTEE WITHIN FIVE BUSINESS DAYS. SUCH REVIEW
COMMITTEE SHALL MAKE A FORMAL RECOMMENDATION TO KEEP, REMOVE, OR
RESTRICT ACCESS TO THE INSTRUCTIONAL MATERIAL THAT IS THE SUBJECT OF
SUCH FORMAL COMPLAINT TO THE SCHOOL BOARD OF THAT SCHOOL DISTRICT WITHIN
THIRTY BUSINESS DAYS. SUCH SCHOOL BOARD WILL VOTE TO APPROVE OR DENY
SUCH RECOMMENDATION AT THE NEXT REGULARLY SCHEDULED MEETING OF SUCH
BOARD AND WILL ALLOW FOR PUBLIC COMMENT REGARDING SUCH RECOMMENDATION AT
SUCH MEETING.
2. FORMAL COMPLAINTS SHALL:
(A) BE IN WRITING OR ELECTRONIC MAIL FORM;
(B) SPECIFY THE COMPLAINT AS BEING A FORMAL COMPLAINT ABOUT INSTRUC-
TIONAL MATERIAL;
(C) PROVIDE A SOURCE CITATION FOR THE CHALLENGED MATERIAL;
(D) REQUEST THAT THE CHALLENGED MATERIAL BE REVIEWED FOR APPROPRIATE-
NESS; AND
(E) SPECIFY WHY THE COMPLAINANT BELIEVES THE CONTENT OF SUCH CHAL-
LENGED MATERIAL TO BE INAPPROPRIATE OR VIOLATIVE OF SCHOOL POLICY.
3. EACH SCHOOL DISTRICT SHALL ESTABLISH A POLICY THAT LAYS OUT A PROC-
ESS BY WHICH FORMAL COMPLAINTS SHALL BE MADE, INCLUDING THE FORM IN
WHICH SUCH COMPLAINTS SHALL BE SUBMITTED.
4. (A) UPON RECEIPT OF A FORMAL COMPLAINT PURSUANT TO THIS SECTION,
THE SUPERINTENDENT OF A SCHOOL DISTRICT SHALL:
(I) REFER THE FORMAL COMPLAINT TO A REVIEW COMMITTEE FOR THE PURPOSE
OF REVIEWING THE FORMAL COMPLAINT AND MAKING RECOMMENDATION TO THE BOARD
OF EDUCATION FOR THAT SCHOOL DISTRICT;
(II) PROVIDE, DURING THE INITIAL FIFTEEN BUSINESS DAYS OF THE REVIEW
COMMITTEE'S RECEIPT OF THE FORMAL COMPLAINT, THE REVIEW COMMITTEE WITH
RECORDS OF ANY CORRESPONDENCE REGARDING THE CHALLENGED MATERIAL THAT THE
SCHOOL DISTRICT HAS RECEIVED FROM ANY RESIDENTS OF SUCH SCHOOL DISTRICT
A. 8828 3
DURING SUCH FIFTEEN BUSINESS DAY PERIOD OR WITHIN THE PRIOR CALENDAR
YEAR;
(III) NOTIFY THE PUBLIC BY POSTING INFORMATION ON ITS WEBSITE THAT THE
REVIEW COMMITTEE WILL COMMENCE REVIEW OF A CHALLENGED MATERIAL AND THAT
THE PUBLIC MAY SUBMIT PUBLIC COMMENTS WITHIN FIFTEEN BUSINESS DAYS FOR
SUCH REVIEW COMMITTEE TO ACCEPT AND EXAMINE. SUCH NOTIFICATION SHALL:
INCLUDE THE SOURCE CITATION FOR THE CHALLENGED MATERIAL; INFORM THE
DISTRICT RESIDENTS THAT THE REVIEW COMMITTEE WILL ACCEPT WRITTEN
COMMENTS FOR REVIEW FOR THE INITIAL FIFTEEN BUSINESS DAYS OF THE REVIEW
PROCESS PURSUANT TO SUBPARAGRAPH (II) OF THIS PARAGRAPH; AND SPECIFY
THAT THE REVIEW COMMITTEE WILL MAKE A RECOMMENDATION TO THE SCHOOL BOARD
TO KEEP, REMOVE, OR RESTRICT ACCESS TO THE INSTRUCTIONAL MATERIAL THAT
IS THE SUBJECT OF SUCH FORMAL COMPLAINT NO LATER THAN THIRTY BUSINESS
DAYS AFTER THE COMMENCEMENT OF THE REVIEW PROCESS, PROVIDED, HOWEVER,
THAT IF SUCH REVIEW PROCESS IS COMPLETED LESS THAN SEVENTY-TWO HOURS
BEFORE THE NEXT REGULARLY SCHEDULED MEETING OF THE BOARD OF EDUCATION
FOR THAT SCHOOL DISTRICT, SUCH RECOMMENDATION SHALL BE TAKEN UP AT THE
NEXT SUCCEEDING REGULARLY SCHEDULED MEETING OF SUCH BOARD;
(IV) NOTIFY THE COMPLAINANT THAT THE REVIEW COMMITTEE WILL BE MAKING A
RECOMMENDATION TO KEEP, REMOVE, OR RESTRICT ACCESS TO THE CHALLENGED
MATERIAL THAT IS THE SUBJECT OF A FORMAL COMPLAINT TO THE BOARD OF
EDUCATION OF THAT SCHOOL DISTRICT AT AN OPEN MEETING OF SUCH BOARD, AND
THAT SUCH COMPLAINANT SHALL HAVE THE OPPORTUNITY TO GIVE PUBLIC COMMENT
AT SUCH MEETING, AT LEAST SEVENTY-TWO HOURS IN ADVANCE OF SUCH MEETING;
(V) NOTIFY THE PUBLIC THAT THE REVIEW COMMITTEE WILL BE MAKING A
RECOMMENDATION TO KEEP, REMOVE, OR RESTRICT ACCESS TO THE CHALLENGED
MATERIAL THAT IS THE SUBJECT OF A FORMAL COMPLAINT TO THE BOARD OF
EDUCATION OF THAT SCHOOL DISTRICT AT AN OPEN MEETING OF SUCH BOARD, AND
THAT THE PUBLIC SHALL HAVE THE OPPORTUNITY TO GIVE PUBLIC COMMENT AT
SUCH MEETING, AT LEAST SEVENTY-TWO HOURS IN ADVANCE OF SUCH MEETING.
SUCH NOTICE SHALL INCLUDE THE SOURCE CITATION INFORMATION OF SUCH CHAL-
LENGED MATERIAL; AND
(VI) MAKE AVAILABLE THE SOURCE CITATION OF SUCH INSTRUCTIONAL MATERIAL
AND THE FORMAL COMPLAINT, WITH IDENTIFYING INFORMATION OF THE COMPLAIN-
ANT REDACTED, BY POSTING ON A REGULARLY AND ROUTINELY UPDATED WEBSITE
MAINTAINED BY SUCH BOARD TO THE EXTENT PRACTICABLE AT LEAST SEVENTY-TWO
HOURS PRIOR TO THE MEETING OF THE BOARD OF EDUCATION FOR THAT SCHOOL
DISTRICT DURING WHICH SUCH COMPLAINT SHALL BE THE SUBJECT OF DISCUSSION.
(B) (I) UPON RECEIPT OF A FORMAL COMPLAINT, A REVIEW COMMITTEE SHALL:
(A) PERFORM A THOROUGH REVIEW OF THE FORMAL COMPLAINT AND CHALLENGED
MATERIAL IN A TIMELY MANNER, PROVIDED, HOWEVER, THAT SUCH REVIEW SHALL
BE COMPLETED NO LATER THAN THIRTY BUSINESS DAYS AFTER THE RECEIPT OF
SUCH FORMAL COMPLAINT, UNLESS AN EXTENSION IS REQUESTED PURSUANT TO
SUBPARAGRAPH (II) OF THIS PARAGRAPH; AND
(B) ACCEPT AND REVIEW, DURING THE FIRST FIFTEEN BUSINESS DAYS OF THE
REVIEW PROCESS, ANY CORRESPONDENCE REGARDING THE CHALLENGED MATERIAL
THAT THE SCHOOL DISTRICT HAS RECEIVED FROM ANY RESIDENTS OF SUCH SCHOOL
DISTRICT DURING SUCH FIFTEEN BUSINESS DAY PERIOD OR WITHIN THE PRIOR
CALENDAR YEAR.
(II) AN EXTENSION OF TEN ADDITIONAL BUSINESS DAYS TO THE THIRTY BUSI-
NESS DAY REVIEW PERIOD MAY BE REQUESTED BY THE REVIEW COMMITTEE IN THE
EVENT THAT THERE IS AN ABUNDANCE OF COMMENTS REGARDING THE CHALLENGED
MATERIAL RECEIVED WITHIN THE FIRST FIFTEEN BUSINESS DAYS OF THE REVIEW
PROCESS.
(C) UPON COMPLETION OF A REVIEW PROCESS, A REVIEW COMMITTEE SHALL:
A. 8828 4
(I) NOTIFY THE SCHOOL SUPERINTENDENT AND BOARD OF EDUCATION OF THAT
SCHOOL DISTRICT THAT THE REVIEW COMMITTEE HAS MADE A DECISION AND WILL
BE MAKING A RECOMMENDATION TO KEEP, REMOVE, OR RESTRICT ACCESS TO THE
CHALLENGED MATERIAL THAT IS THE SUBJECT OF A FORMAL COMPLAINT TO SUCH
BOARD AT THE NEXT REGULARLY SCHEDULED MEETING OF SUCH BOARD, PROVIDED,
HOWEVER, THAT IF SUCH REVIEW PROCESS IS COMPLETED LESS THAN SEVENTY-TWO
HOURS BEFORE THE NEXT REGULARLY SCHEDULED MEETING OF THE BOARD OF EDUCA-
TION FOR THAT SCHOOL DISTRICT, SUCH RECOMMENDATION SHALL BE TAKEN UP AT
THE NEXT SUCCEEDING REGULARLY SCHEDULED MEETING OF SUCH BOARD;
(II) MAKE A RECOMMENDATION TO SUCH BOARD TO KEEP, REMOVE, OR RESTRICT
ACCESS, BY AGE OR GRADE LEVEL, OR BY REQUIRING PARENTAL PERMISSION, TO
THE CHALLENGED MATERIAL THAT IS THE SUBJECT OF A FORMAL COMPLAINT AT THE
NEXT REGULARLY SCHEDULED MEETING OF SUCH BOARD.
(D) UPON RECEIPT OF A RECOMMENDATION FROM A REVIEW COMMITTEE TO KEEP,
REMOVE, OR RESTRICT ACCESS TO THE CHALLENGED MATERIAL THAT IS THE
SUBJECT OF A FORMAL COMPLAINT, A BOARD OF EDUCATION FOR A SCHOOL
DISTRICT SHALL VOTE TO KEEP, REMOVE, OR RESTRICT ACCESS TO SUCH CHAL-
LENGED MATERIAL AT A REGULARLY SCHEDULED MEETING OF SUCH BOARD, AND
ALLOW TIME FOR PUBLIC COMMENT BY SCHOOL DISTRICT RESIDENTS OR PARENTS OR
GUARDIANS OF STUDENTS ATTENDING THAT SCHOOL DISTRICT REGARDING SUCH
CHALLENGED MATERIAL AT SUCH MEETING IMMEDIATELY PRIOR TO SUCH VOTE. EACH
MEMBER OF THE PUBLIC AUTHORIZED TO MAKE PUBLIC COMMENTS SHALL BE ALLOWED
UP TO THREE MINUTES TO SPEAK AT THE MEETING OF THE BOARD PRIOR TO SUCH
VOTE.
§ 734. ACCESSIBLE PUBLIC DATABASE. EACH SCHOOL DISTRICT SHALL MAINTAIN
AN ACCESSIBLE PUBLIC DATABASE PURSUANT TO SUBDIVISION NINE OF SECTION
SEVEN HUNDRED ONE OF THIS TITLE. SUCH PUBLIC DATABASE SHALL BE MAIN-
TAINED REGULARLY AND UPDATED UPON THE ACQUISITION OF ANY NEW INSTRUC-
TIONAL MATERIALS AND DISCONTINUATION OF USE OF ANY INSTRUCTIONAL MATERI-
AL BY THE SCHOOL DISTRICT. SUCH PUBLIC DATABASE ALSO SHALL BE SEARCHABLE
BY SOURCE CITATION DATA.
§ 3. Section 1501-b of the education law is amended by adding a new
subdivision 5 to read as follows:
5. THE BOARD OF EDUCATION OF ANY SCHOOL DISTRICT IS AUTHORIZED AND
EMPOWERED TO APPROVE OR DENY A RECOMMENDATION BY A REVIEW COMMITTEE, AS
DEFINED BY SUBDIVISION FIVE OF SECTION SEVEN HUNDRED THIRTY-ONE OF THIS
CHAPTER, TO KEEP, REMOVE OR RESTRICT ACCESS TO A CHALLENGED MATERIAL, AS
DEFINED BY SUBDIVISION TWO OF SECTION SEVEN HUNDRED THIRTY-ONE OF THIS
CHAPTER. WHEN SUCH RECOMMENDATION IS SCHEDULED TO BE THE SUBJECT OF
DISCUSSION AND SUBSEQUENT ACTION BY A BOARD OF EDUCATION DURING AN OPEN
MEETING, SUCH BOARD SHALL MAKE AVAILABLE THE SOURCE CITATION OF SUCH
CHALLENGED MATERIALS BY POSTING SUCH INFORMATION ON A REGULARLY AND
ROUTINELY UPDATED WEBSITE MAINTAINED BY SUCH BOARD TO THE EXTENT PRACTI-
CABLE AT LEAST SEVENTY-TWO HOURS PRIOR TO SUCH MEETING.
§ 4. Section 701 of the education law is amended by adding a new
subdivision 9 to read as follows:
9. IN THE SEVERAL CITIES AND SCHOOL DISTRICTS OF THE STATE, BOARD OF
EDUCATION, TRUSTEES OR SUCH BODY OR OFFICER AS PERFORM THE FUNCTIONS OF
SUCH BOARDS, SHALL MAINTAIN AN ONLINE DATABASE LISTING THE SOURCE CITA-
TIONS OF ALL INSTRUCTIONAL MATERIALS, DESIGNATED PURSUANT TO SUBDIVISION
ONE OF THIS SECTION, THAT ARE IN USE IN SUCH SCHOOL DISTRICT FOR TEACH-
ING AND SUPPORT OF LEARNING BY STUDENTS IN THE SCHOOLS UNDER THEIR
CHARGE. SUCH DATABASE SHALL BE MADE ACCESSIBLE TO PARENTS AND GUARDIANS
OF STUDENTS ATTENDING SUCH SCHOOL DISTRICT. SUCH PUBLIC DATABASE SHALL
BE MAINTAINED REGULARLY AND UPDATED UPON THE ACQUISITION OF ANY NEW
INSTRUCTIONAL MATERIALS AND DISCONTINUATION OF USE OF ANY INSTRUCTIONAL
A. 8828 5
MATERIAL BY THE SCHOOL DISTRICT. SUCH PUBLIC DATABASE ALSO SHALL BE
SEARCHABLE BY SOURCE CITATION DATA.
§ 5. Subdivision (e) of section 103 of the public officers law, as
amended by chapter 481 of the laws of 2021, is amended to read as
follows:
(e) 1. Agency records available to the public pursuant to article six
of this chapter, as well as any proposed resolution, law, rule, regu-
lation, policy or any amendment thereto, that is scheduled to be the
subject of discussion by a public body during an open meeting shall be
made available, upon request therefor, to the extent practicable at
least twenty-four hours prior to the meeting during which the records
will be discussed. Copies of such records may be made available for a
reasonable fee, determined in the same manner as provided therefor in
article six of this chapter. If the agency in which a public body func-
tions maintains a regularly and routinely updated website and utilizes a
high speed internet connection, such records shall be posted on the
website to the extent practicable at least twenty-four hours prior to
the meeting. An agency may, but shall not be required to, expend addi-
tional moneys to implement the provisions of this subdivision.
2. IF A VOTE TO APPROVE OR DENY A RECOMMENDATION BY A REVIEW COMMIT-
TEE, AS DEFINED IN SUBDIVISION FIVE OF SECTION SEVEN HUNDRED THIRTY-ONE
OF THE EDUCATION LAW, TO KEEP, REMOVE, OR RESTRICT ACCESS TO AN INSTRUC-
TIONAL MATERIAL, AS DEFINED BY SUBDIVISION ONE OF SECTION SEVEN HUNDRED
THIRTY-ONE OF THE EDUCATION LAW, THAT IS THE SUBJECT OF A FORMAL
COMPLAINT, AS DEFINED BY SUBDIVISION FOUR OF SECTION SEVEN HUNDRED THIR-
TY-ONE OF THE EDUCATION LAW, IS SCHEDULED TO BE THE SUBJECT OF
DISCUSSION BY A BOARD OF EDUCATION DURING AN OPEN MEETING, THE SOURCE
CITATION OF SUCH INSTRUCTIONAL MATERIAL AND THE FORMAL COMPLAINT, WITH
IDENTIFYING INFORMATION OF THE COMPLAINANT REDACTED, SHALL BE MADE
AVAILABLE BY POSTING ON A REGULARLY AND ROUTINELY UPDATED WEBSITE MAIN-
TAINED BY SUCH BOARD TO THE EXTENT PRACTICABLE AT LEAST SEVENTY-TWO
HOURS PRIOR TO THE MEETING DURING WHICH SUCH VOTE SHALL TAKE PLACE.
§ 6. Section 751 of the education law is amended by adding a new
subdivision 5 to read as follows:
5. THE COMMISSIONER, IN ADDITION TO THE ANNUAL APPORTIONMENT OF PUBLIC
MONIES PURSUANT TO OTHER ARTICLES OF THIS CHAPTER, SHALL APPORTION EACH
SCHOOL DISTRICT AN AMOUNT EQUAL TO THE COST OF THE CREATION AND/OR MAIN-
TENANCE OF AN ONLINE INSTRUCTIONAL MATERIALS DATABASE REQUIRED PURSUANT
TO SUBDIVISION NINE OF SECTION SEVEN HUNDRED ONE OF THIS CHAPTER.
§ 7. This act shall take effect immediately.