BILL NUMBER: S2659A

SPONSOR: COMRIE
 
TITLE OF BILL:

An act to amend the general business law, in relation to notification of
a data breach

 
SUMMARY OF PROVISIONS:

This bill amends existing subdivisions 2 and 3 of section 899-aa of the
general business law to provide that consumer reporting agencies that
experience a data breach must disclose such breach within 15 days.

 
JUSTIFICATION:

On September 7th, 2017, one of three major consumer credit reporting
agencies in the United States-Equifax-reported that hackers gained
access to company data that potentially compromised sensitive informa-
tion for 143 million American consumers - nearly 44% of the U.S. popu-
lation. The breach included: social security numbers, driver's license
numbers, names, addresses and birth dates. Keys that unlock consumers'
              

medical histories, bank accounts, and employee accounts have also been
compromised. Credit card numbers for 209,000 consumers were stolen, and
documents with personal information used in disputes for 182,000 people
were also stolen.

The attack on Equifax represents one of the largest risks to personally
sensitive information in recent years. This incident is the third major
cybersecurity threat for the agency since 2015. Just last year, identify
thieves successfully hacked critical W-2 tax and salary data from an
Equifax website. Earlier this year, thieves again stole W-2 tax data
from an Equifax subsidiary, TAM which provides online payroll, tax and
human resources services to some of the nation's largest corporations.
According to investigations, criminals gained access to certain files in
the company's system from mid-May to July, 2017 by exploiting a weak
point in website software.

Identity thieves can impersonate people with lenders, creditors, and
service providers who rely on personal identity information. Thieves can
also use stored information from Equifax and use it to open accounts
with creditors that use Experian or TransUnion.  Cybersecurity profes-
sionals criticized Equifax for not improving its security practices
after previous thefts. Critics also argue that Equifax should have
multiple layers of controls. Consumers complained of a 6-week lag
between the discovery of the attack and Equifax's public disclosure.
Equifax discovered the intrusion on July 29th but it first disclosed the
attack publicly on September 7th.

There seems to be a broad sense of uncertainty by experts and lawmakers
as to which federal regulations, if any, is charged with the responsi-
bility to monitor and do regular supervision on cybersecurity. The
Consumer Financial Protection Bureau has authority to police violations
of consumer protection laws by consumer credit bureaus, but the agency
generally leaves data privacy enforcement to the FederAP Commission.
However, the Trade Commission lacks the authority to impose big fines or
authorize fines for first time violations of certain rules. Neither have
commented on applicable law or jurisdiction. Although federal lawmakers
have promised legislation and public hearings, no clear authority is
forthcoming in short order. Thus, it is time for New York State to lead
on this issue, given the fact that millions of our residents were
exposed in this episode.

TO THIS END, THIS LEGISLATION PROVIDES A CLEAR CONSUMER PROTECTION
MANDATE THAT WILL AGGRESSIVELY PROTECT CONSUMERS BY MANDATING TIMELY
DISCLOSURE OF DATA BEACHES BY CREDIT REPORTING AGENCIES.

 
LEGISLATIVE HISTORY:

S5808 2022

S6880 COMRIE No Same as ON FILE: 01/03/18 General Business Law

 
TITLE:

to notification of a data breach 09/20/17 REFERRED TO RULES 01/03/18
REFERRED TO CONSUMER PROTECTION

 
FISCAL IMPLICATIONS:

None noted for. the state; the design of the legislation could signif-
icant save money for consumers.

 
EFFECTIVE DATE:
This act shall take effect immediately.

                                 
BILL NUMBER: S2659B

SPONSOR: COMRIE
 
TITLE OF BILL:

An act to amend the general business law, in relation to notification of
a data breach

 
SUMMARY OF PROVISIONS:

This bill amends existing subdivisions 2 and 3 of section 899-aa of the
general business law to provide that consumer reporting agencies that
experience a data breach must disclose such breach within 30 days.

 
JUSTIFICATION:

On September 7th, 2017, one of three major consumer credit reporting
agencies in the United States-Equifax-reported that hackers gained
access to company data that potentially compromised sensitive informa-
tion for 143 million American consumers - nearly 44% of the U.S. popu-
lation. The breach included: social security numbers, driver's license
numbers, names, addresses and birth dates. Keys that unlock consumers'
              

medical histories, bank accounts, and employee accounts have also been
compromised. Credit card numbers for 209,000 consumers were stolen, and
documents with personal information used in disputes for 182,000 people
were also stolen.

The attack on Equifax represents one of the largest risks to personally
sensitive information in recent years. This incident is the third major
cybersecurity threat for the agency since 2015. Just last year, identify
thieves successfully hacked critical W-2 tax and salary data from an
Equifax website. Earlier this year, thieves again stole W-2 tax data
from an Equifax subsidiary, TAM which provides online payroll, tax and
human resources services to some of the nation's largest corporations.
According to investigations, criminals gained access to certain files in
the company's system from mid-May to July, 2017 by exploiting a weak
point in website software.

Identity thieves can impersonate people with lenders, creditors, and
service providers who rely on personal identity information. Thieves can
also use stored information from Equifax and use it to open accounts
with creditors that use Experian or TransUnion.  Cybersecurity profes-
sionals criticized Equifax for not improving its security practices
after previous thefts. Critics also argue that Equifax should have
multiple layers of controls. Consumers complained of a 6-week lag
between the discovery of the attack and Equifax's public disclosure.
Equifax discovered the intrusion on July 29th but it first disclosed the
attack publicly on September 7th.

There seems to be a broad sense of uncertainty by experts and lawmakers
as to which federal regulations, if any, is charged with the responsi-
bility to monitor and do regular supervision on cybersecurity. The
Consumer Financial Protection Bureau has authority to police violations
of consumer protection laws by consumer credit bureaus, but the agency
generally leaves data privacy enforcement to the FederAP Commission.
However, the Trade Commission lacks the authority to impose big fines or
authorize fines for first time violations of certain rules. Neither have
commented on applicable law or jurisdiction. Although federal lawmakers
have promised legislation and public hearings, no clear authority is
forthcoming in short order. Thus, it is time for New York State to lead
on this issue, given the fact that millions of our residents were
exposed in this episode.

TO THIS END, THIS LEGISLATION PROVIDES A CLEAR CONSUMER PROTECTION
MANDATE THAT WILL AGGRESSIVELY PROTECT CONSUMERS BY MANDATING TIMELY
DISCLOSURE OF DATA BEACHES BY CREDIT REPORTING AGENCIES.

 
LEGISLATIVE HISTORY:

S5808 2022 S6880 COMRIE No Same as ON FILE: 01/03/18 General Business
Law

 
TITLE:

to notification of a data breach 09/20/17 REFERRED TO RULES 01/03/18
REFERRED TO CONSUMER PROTECTION

 
FISCAL IMPLICATIONS:

None noted for. the state; the design of the legislation could signif-
icant save money for consumers.

 
EFFECTIVE DATE:
This act shall take effect immediately.