Legislation
SECTION 19-0511
Review by the courts
Environmental Conservation (ENV) CHAPTER 43-B, ARTICLE 19, TITLE 5
§ 19-0511. Review by the courts.
1. Any final order or determination or other final action by the
commissioner and the validity or reasonableness of any code, rule or
regulation promulgated by the department pursuant to this article shall
be subject to review as provided in article 78 of the Civil Practice Law
and Rules.
2. When a review in accordance with article 78 of the Civil Practice
Law and Rules is not maintainable, either because the person aggrieved
was not a party to the original proceedings in which the order or
determination or other action which is sought to be reviewed was made or
taken, or for any other reason, the order or determination of the
commissioner and the validity or reasonableness of any code, rule or
regulation of the department promulgated pursuant to this article may
nevertheless be reviewed as hereinafter provided:
a. Application for relief from any code, rule or regulation of the
department or from any determination or order or other action which
shall have been made or taken by the commissioner or by any person
acting in the name of the department or commissioner shall be made by
special proceeding. The petition shall be verified and shall set forth
the code, rule or regulation or the determination or order or other
action of the department or commissioner or the part thereof which the
petitioner shall claim to be unreasonable or prejudicial to him and
shall specify the grounds therefor. Such petition may be accompanied by
affidavits or other written proof and shall demand the relief to which
the petitioner alleges he is entitled, in the alternative or otherwise.
Such petition may be made by any one or more persons jointly or
severally who shall be aggrieved by any such code, rule or regulation or
any such determination, order or act whether or not such petitioner is
or was a party to the proceeding in which such code, rule or regulation
was adopted by the department or in which such determination or order or
action was made or taken by the commissioner.
b. A proceeding brought under the provisions of this subdivision must
be instituted by service of the petition and notices of application for
relief within two months after the action of the department or
commissioner which is sought to be reviewed shall become final and
binding upon the petitioner or the person whom he represents either in
law or in fact; or, with the permission of the supreme court granted
within two years in case the petitioner or the person whom he
represented at the time such action became final and binding upon the
petitioner or such person was under the age of twenty-one years, or
mentally ill, or imprisoned on a criminal charge, or had been sentenced
for a term of less than life.
c. In all other respects the procedure prescribed in subdivision 1 of
this section shall be applicable to a review provided for in this
subdivision.
1. Any final order or determination or other final action by the
commissioner and the validity or reasonableness of any code, rule or
regulation promulgated by the department pursuant to this article shall
be subject to review as provided in article 78 of the Civil Practice Law
and Rules.
2. When a review in accordance with article 78 of the Civil Practice
Law and Rules is not maintainable, either because the person aggrieved
was not a party to the original proceedings in which the order or
determination or other action which is sought to be reviewed was made or
taken, or for any other reason, the order or determination of the
commissioner and the validity or reasonableness of any code, rule or
regulation of the department promulgated pursuant to this article may
nevertheless be reviewed as hereinafter provided:
a. Application for relief from any code, rule or regulation of the
department or from any determination or order or other action which
shall have been made or taken by the commissioner or by any person
acting in the name of the department or commissioner shall be made by
special proceeding. The petition shall be verified and shall set forth
the code, rule or regulation or the determination or order or other
action of the department or commissioner or the part thereof which the
petitioner shall claim to be unreasonable or prejudicial to him and
shall specify the grounds therefor. Such petition may be accompanied by
affidavits or other written proof and shall demand the relief to which
the petitioner alleges he is entitled, in the alternative or otherwise.
Such petition may be made by any one or more persons jointly or
severally who shall be aggrieved by any such code, rule or regulation or
any such determination, order or act whether or not such petitioner is
or was a party to the proceeding in which such code, rule or regulation
was adopted by the department or in which such determination or order or
action was made or taken by the commissioner.
b. A proceeding brought under the provisions of this subdivision must
be instituted by service of the petition and notices of application for
relief within two months after the action of the department or
commissioner which is sought to be reviewed shall become final and
binding upon the petitioner or the person whom he represents either in
law or in fact; or, with the permission of the supreme court granted
within two years in case the petitioner or the person whom he
represented at the time such action became final and binding upon the
petitioner or such person was under the age of twenty-one years, or
mentally ill, or imprisoned on a criminal charge, or had been sentenced
for a term of less than life.
c. In all other respects the procedure prescribed in subdivision 1 of
this section shall be applicable to a review provided for in this
subdivision.