Senator Montgomery urges Community Board 2 to stand with the community to reject Alloy Development and the ECF’s applications to rezone 80 Flatbush Avenue.
March 28, 2018
-
ISSUE:
- Community Development
- Housing Development
- Education
- Public Assets
- Infrastructure and Government Investment
On March 28th, Senator Montgomery submitted comments to Community Board 2 on Alloy Development and the NYC Educational Construction Fund’s applications to rezone 80 Flatbush Avenue. Senator Montgomery joined the residents of State Street and 1 Hanson Place along with the Boerum Hill Association, the Fort Greene Association, the Society for Clinton Hill and Community Education Council District 15 in expressing opposition to this massive development project.
Alloy Development's proposal for 80 Flatbush Avenue is located in the residential neighborhood of Boerum Hill and is bounded by Flatbush and Third Avenues and State and Schermerhorn Streets. The public cost of tax-exempt bonds and city or state subsidies and tax abatements for this development remain unknown. The project requires zoning changes to:
- Allow for the construction of two (74- and 38-story) high rise towers, the largest of which would almost double the height of the Williamsburg Savings Bank building
- Triple the Floor Area Ratio from 6.5 to 18
- Create 900 new apartments (700 market-rate units/200 "affordable" units)
Senator Montgomery's statement to Community Board 2 details her concerns and reads as follows:
Comments to Community Board 2 on Alloy Development and the NYC Educational Construction Fund’s applications to rezone 80 Flatbush Avenue
Good evening Chairperson McRae, members of Community Board 2, neighbors and community stakeholders.
Thank you for the opportunity to submit comments on the applications to rezone 80 Flatbush Avenue as proposed by Alloy Development and the New York City Educational Construction Fund (ECF). Let me begin by saying that I am unequivocally against using public resources to support the proposed development of 80 Flatbush Avenue.
While I recognize the extensive capital needs of the Khalil Gibran International Academy and support the involvement of the Fifth Avenue Committee on this project, the overstated public benefits do not outweigh the potential damage to our community and the millions in lost property tax revenue. Limited government resources should be used to support non-profit housing organizations that build truly affordable housing for a fraction of the cost.
I stand with my constituents and the community in saying, enough is enough. We are tired of the destruction of the social fabric of our neighborhoods, the displacement of longtime residents and the gentrification that has changed Brooklyn from a borough of brownstones to a borough of skyscrapers.
Our seniors can no longer afford to stay in their homes and our children cannot afford to live in the neighborhoods where they were raised. 60,000 New Yorkers live in shelters and millions of workers who are the backbone of our economy struggle against the tide of homelessness. The very culture, character, and spirit of our neighborhoods that attracted people to come here is dying and developments like 80 Flatbush are killing it.
Let me be clear. I am not against development. I am against socially irresponsible, out of scale, over development. I am against taxpayers subsidizing private developers under the guise of public benefits. I am against myopic city planning that evaluates projects individually rather than within the context of community development. I am against homeowners and small business owners bearing the weight of escalating property tax bills because new development projects are exempted from contributing to city and state tax coffers for decades. I am against the lack of planning that enables massive development projects to be built without consideration for the burdens placed on New York City’s aging infrastructure.
Last July, Assemblywoman Joanne Simon and I submitted joint comments on the Draft Scope of Work for the Preparation of the Environmental Impact Statement for this site. We are disappointed that our request for the expansion of the proposed study area from 400 feet to at least (1) square mile was not granted. For a project of this size, which triples the FAR of an as-of-right development under a C6-2 zoning, 400 feet is entirely too small to adequately evaluate the impact of this proposed development on its surrounding area. I urge everyone to read our scoping comments which detail our numerous concerns about this project.
I am also troubled that the project’s final scope of work confirms that although “the proposed project would add new population which could have a higher average household income than the average household income in the study area, the proposed project would not introduce or accelerate the existing trend of changing socioeconomic conditions. There is already a readily observable trend toward higher incomes, new market-rate residential development, and increasing rents in the study area.”
To acknowledge increased rents and the trend of market rate housing development is to admit that gentrification is already rampant in our community. However, the most concerning part is that ECF essentially admits that because displacement and gentrification already exists and continues to grow, they have no problem with perpetuating this trend and exasperating the problem.
We should not be forced to accept the larger structures, the public subsidy giveaways, the inadequate affordable housing and our communities living in permanent shadows. I respectfully request that Community Board 2 stand with us to reject Alloy Development and the ECF’s applications to rezone 80 Flatbush Avenue.
To read Senator Montgomery and Assemblywoman Simon's joint scoping comments, download the PDF.
To learn more about Senator Montgomery's work on this issue, visit:
To learn more about how the communty stands on this project, visit:
http://boerumhillassociation.org/home.aspx
https://www.mas.org/news/mas-opposed-to-80-flatbush-avenue-rezoning-proposal/
To learn more about the 80 Flatbush Avenue project, visit:
https://www.brownstoner.com/development/brooklyn-development-80-flatbush-avenue-downtown-brooklyn-public-hearing/
http://www.brooklyneagle.com/articles/2018/3/29/supertall-skyscraper-plan-80-flatbush-ave-sparks-neighbors-ire
https://bklyner.com/save-our-sunlight-protesters-rally-against-alloys-shadow-casting-towers/
https://thebridgebk.com/brooklyn-towers-reach-sky-how-big-too-big/
https://www.brooklynpaper.com/stories/41/13/dtg-web-80-flatbush-ulurp-hearing-2018-03-30-bk.html